Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 Convertible Crib Review

Choosing the right crib for your baby can be a tough decision. Parents often find themselves torn between affordability, safety, and style.

The Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib appears to offer everything you could want: it has a convertible design that grows with your child and boasts an affordable price tag. If you are concerned about whether this affordable crib won’t meet your expectations, our Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib review can help.

In this review, we’ll break down our findings on the Storkcraft Tuscany, exploring its assembly, durability, safety features, and overall value. Based on a blend of verified data, our testing, and parent reviews, here’s what you need to know about the crib.

Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 Convertible Crib: In-Depth Breakdown

1. Assembly and Setup

Overall, I’d rate the ease of setup as moderate. It wasn’t the simplest crib we’d put together, but it certainly wasn’t the hardest. The assembly required a bit of time and attention to detail, especially when ensuring everything was tightened properly.

One positive aspect is that none of the pieces are too heavy, making it manageable without requiring much strength. The assembly instructions are mostly clear, although there are a few steps that could be explained more clearly. Some of the diagrams could have been larger and more detailed, especially in areas such as aligning the slats or attaching the mattress platform.

Although a few parents reported that the parts on their Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib did not align properly, all the screws on our model fit as they should, and we did not run into any issues with misaligned holes or hardware.

• Time to Assemble: ~ 1 hour (It might take a bit longer for first-timers or if you’re working alone)
• Tools Required: Included Allen wrench
• Ease of Setup: Moderate, better with two people

2. Safety and Stability

In our tests, we applied pressure to simulate a child leaning and jumping in the crib. The Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib remained stable with no wobbling or shifting, so we concluded it withstands normal use well.

Transitioning the crib into its toddler and daybed forms also didn’t compromise its sturdiness, although extra care may be needed when tightening screws during conversions to maintain that stability.

There is very little information available about the safety of this crib compared to other cribs, which is unusual considering that parents usually prioritize safety when choosing a crib for their children.

The Storkcraft Tuscany crib does meet the safety standards set by the CPSC (Consumer Product Safety Commission). We know this because selling would be illegal if the crib didn’t meet these standards. Nevertheless, the lack of information is causing confusion among parents who are searching for details about the crib online, thus we are not impressed.

• Safety Standards: Meets standards but lacks detailed Info
• Safety Certification: JPMA, Greenguard Gold
• Stability: Good

3. Durability and Build Quality

Based on our assessment, the Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib provides moderate durability for its price range.

The crib is made of solid wood, which is good. However, the wood used in this model is relatively soft, making it more likely to get dented and scratched. While it seems strong at first, the soft wood is more prone to getting cosmetic damage over time.

During our scratch and dent tests, where we simulated regular contact such as toys, belts, and bumping against walls, we found that the finish on the crib is prone to scratching. The paint can chip easily if struck by harder objects, and noticeable dents can appear if the crib is knocked or bumped with force.

This won’t affect how strong the crib is, but it could be a problem if parents want to keep it looking new.

However, we did notice that with repeated conversions and mattress height adjustments, there is a slight risk of loosening around the screw holes. The more you tighten and loosen the screws, the less sturdy the crib might become, especially in the corners and joints.

So, while the crib holds up well for the first child, families planning to pass it down to multiple children might face a few structural issues over time, such as small wobbles or screws that don’t grip as securely after multiple uses.

• Material: Pine wood and composites
• Durability Rating: A mixed bag

4. Mattress Fit and Height Adjustability

We tested the Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib with a standard-sized crib mattress, the Newton Baby crib mattress, which is the size the manufacturer recommends. The mattress fits snugly inside the crib without leaving any dangerous gaps on any side, ensuring a secure sleeping environment for the baby.

This crib has a metal spring support, which is great as it allows better breathability. It distributed weight evenly without sagging during our testing. It is adjustable to three height positions. Adjusting the mattress height is simple and doesn’t take much time. However, to move it to a new position, you’ll need to remove the mattress and unbolt the support frame from the crib base.

• Mattress Fit: Standard-size crib mattress
• Recommended Crib Mattress: Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress
• Adjustable Mattress Height: 3 levels

5. Convertibility and Versatility

The Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib is designed to grow with your child, converting from a crib into three additional bed types: a toddler bed, a daybed, and a full-size bed with a headboard and footboard. On paper, this makes it an excellent long-term investment for parents who want a crib that can adapt over the years. However, we ran into a few challenges during our testing.

The instructions are clear, and the parts are well-labeled, but you will need some additional tools, such as a wrench and screwdriver. More importantly, when we wanted to purchase a toddler bed safety rail, it was nowhere to be found. Since this is usually an essential feature for parents, it presents quite a problem.

After each conversion, we tested the stability, and the crib remained stable up to the daybed. Then we noticed a bit of damage around the screw holes. For the price you are paying, this is kind of expectable. But you must know that with repeated conversions and mattress height adjustments, there is a risk of loosening around the screw holes.

With some care when making adjustments, the crib should remain stable even when converted to a full-size bed. However, we believe it will only withstand one set of conversions and are doubtful about its durability if passed on to another child.

• Conversion Modes: Crib, toddler bed, daybed, full-size bed (toddler bed and full-size bed conversion kits sold separately / conversion into a daybed do not need other parts)
• Ease of Conversion: Moderate, but the absence of the toddler bed rail adds complexity

6. Design and Aesthetics

The Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 crib has a visually appealing traditional style. It features an elegant yet simple design with soft, curved edges and solid construction. The crib has a smooth surface and an uncluttered appearance, making it an excellent choice for those who like the timeless appeal of the sleigh-style design.

• Aesthetic: Classic but functional
• Color Options: White, Grey, Espresso

7. Price and Value for Money

While the crib itself is affordably priced, the added costs for conversion kits (particularly the toddler rail being unavailable) make it less of a complete package. For parents who are looking for an affordable, stylish crib that offers good functionality in the short term, it presents a solid choice. However, its long-term value might diminish due to durability concerns and the added hassle of finding conversion parts.

• Crib Price: $189.00, with a sale price of $165.77 (As of this review)
• Conversion Kits Sold Separately: Yes (The toddler bed rail is difficult to find, which adds inconvenience and the full-size bed conversion kit costs around $90.)
• Value for Money: Good initial value | Poor long-term value

FAQs about the Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 Convertible Crib

Storkcraft Tuscany vs. Similar Convertible Cribs

In this section, we compare the Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib to three other popular convertible cribs: the DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 convertible crib, the Delta Children Canton 4-in-1 convertible crib, and the Dream On Me Ashton 5-in-1 convertible crib.

Why did we choose these three cribs for comparison? We assumed you might have an eye on the Storkcraft Tuscany crib for its aesthetic appeal and versatility. So, we selected cribs that share a similar design philosophy—classic, convertible, and designed to grow with your child. All of these models are highly regarded in their own right, offering a mix of features that parents look for in a convertible crib.

We have compared their features, such as how easy they are to assemble, how sturdy they are, their mattress support, convertibility, and more. I hope this will help you decide if the Storkcraft Tuscany is the right choice for your baby’s nursery.

The Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 convertible crib offers decent ratings in most categories, but it consistently falls behind Delta Canton and DaVinci Kalani in terms of sturdiness, durability, and convertibility. Delta Canton is the most well-rounded crib, excelling in almost all categories, while DaVinci Kalani offers solid performance in key areas like sturdiness and mattress support. Dream On Me Ashton performs well in ease of assembly and mattress support but is weaker in other areas like design and durability.

For parents considering the Storkcraft Tuscany, it’s a reasonable option if you’re looking for a well-priced crib with decent assembly and mattress support. However, if durability and overall value are your primary concerns, Delta Canton or DaVinci Kalani might be more suitable choices.